The transgender presenter has been at the centre off every row in the Celebrity Big Brother house so far, after protesting that none of her new flatmates see her as a woman.
"But I've put everything aside and I just feel like, you're the person, I don't know if I'm allowed to say this, I feel like we have the least in common".
As she was greeted with applause after exiting, Willoughby looked surprised and said: "I expected a hail of bullets, thanks heavens that wasn't the case".
When Andrew asked if he treats Shane differently when he's dressed as Courtney, Shane continued: "You're more flirtatious, I think understandably so, you're a young viral man with sexual desires, and Courtney is aesthetically a tarty, attractive woman".
India Willoughby has claimed she was "abducted by aliens" when she was younger.
The transgender newsreader was booted from the Borehamwood mansion on Friday night after finding herself in the bottom two with Love Island's Jonny Mitchell. Even I get bored of it!'
'I think I hit a really big one with the gender question.' She was greeted by her mother Sandra, looking emotional as she said 'I missed you!'
It was revealed just after 10.30pm that India received the fewest votes, becoming the first to be evicted.
A stunned India said: "Where did that come from?" I love the experience ... but did I give my best show?
To which Courtney replied: "Obviously I think Andrew is cute".
Regretting some of her actions in the house, India confessed: "I'm not kidding myself, I got it wrong and I know that".
Her housemates weren't so sure, though.
India then turned her attention to her relationship with drag star Courtney Act, echoing the popular opinion that Courtney will win the show.